IRP Cleanup Report 
Volume 3, Issue 1
June 2002


 

New Plume Identified
The Air Force Center for Environmental Excellence (AFCEE) routinely samples monitoring wells located in and around groundwater plume areas. Currently, AFCEE is investigating a new plume. The new area of groundwater contamination is located in the southwest area of the Massachusetts Military Reservation (MMR), between two known plume areas - Chemical Spill 10 (CS-10) and Landfill 1 (LF-1). The contaminant of concern in this area is trichloroethylene (TCE). TCE is a cleaning solvent and has a state and federal drinking water standard (maximum contaminant level or MCL) of 5 parts per billion (ppb). The highest detection in this area for TCE has been 29 ppb. All residences in this area are on the base water supply; thus eliminating any potential risk from exposure to contaminated groundwater. Residential homes immediately downgradient of this area are all on Falmouth municipal water supplied by the town of Falmouth.

There are no municipal wells currently threatened by this new area of groundwater contamination. AFCEE will install additional monitoring wells and resample existing wells to better delineate the nature and extent of contamination. AFCEE will be working closely with the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), and the Massachusetts Department of Public Health (DPH) in reviewing the sampling results and determining the source and extent of this area of groundwater contamination. Periodic updates have been given to the Senior Management Board (SMB) and Plume Cleanup Team (PCT). Officials in the town of Falmouth have been notified.

The Air Force Center for Environmental Excellence (AFCEE) is the agency responsible for the Installation Restoration Program (IRP) at the Massachusetts Military Reservation (MMR).

The IRP is the program to clean up soil and ground water contamination resulting from past practices at MMR. The articles in this newsletter contain information about recent developments in the program. They provide updates on some of the cleanup projects underway and they highlight some of our ongoing community involvement efforts.

We hope that you find this newsletter informative. More information can be found on our web site, www.mmr.org or by calling the IRP Community Involvement office at 508-968-4678, ext. 2.

Map of newly identified plume

For additional information on this project, please contact Doug Karson, Community Involvement Specialist, toll free at (866) GO AFCEE (866-462-3233).

 

AFCEE and Bourne Water District Sign Agreement
AFCEE and the Bourne Water District modified an existing agreement to provide a total of $5.7 million to the Bourne Water District for water supply system projects.

To meet the water demands this summer, Bourne water officials planned to increase the pumping rates of supply wells 2 and 5 near Cataumet. Concerned with the potential of the Landfill 1 (LF-1) groundwater plume being pulled into the district’s wells, AFCEE has sampled three upgradient sentinel wells monthly since 1998 and will continue until the delivery capacity of approximately 1.7 million gallons of water from wells 2 and 5 can be replaced under this agreement. The Bourne Water District will allocate a portion of the $5.7 million to construct a 3-mile pipeline to connect into the Upper Cape Water Supply System and to build a metering/corrosion control facility. Another portion of the funds will be allocated for the development of a new production well site, WS-4, located on the western edge of MMR.

 

MMR Toll Free Number Available (no longer available)

AFCEE has established a toll free number for the
Installation Restoration Program, 1-866-GO-AFCEE
(1-866-462-3233). AFCEE welcomes all calls related to groundwater cleanup progress, private well sampling, recreational uses of ponds, real estate, or other areas of interest regarding the groundwater and soil cleanup programs.

1-866-GO-AFCEE

Underground Storage Tank Removed at CS-4 Site
In February 2002, during planned soil removal at the Chemical Spill 4 (CS-4) source area site on MMR, an underground storage tank (UST) was discovered. Sampling revealed that the UST contained heating oil. The heating oil was removed from the 500 gallon tank and the UST subsequently was removed and taken off-site, in accordance with Commonwealth of Massachusetts regulations. Because it appeared that heating oil may have leaked from the UST, soil surrounding the UST was removed. Analysis of the soils below the UST revealed elevated levels of contaminants. AFCEE is currently performing additional characterization of these soils to determine to what extent these contaminants extend into the ground. Depending on the nature and extent of the contamination, a decision regarding the scope of additional excavation and site assessment will be made.

CS-4 Source AreaThe CS-4 source area site is composed of two areas (northern and southern) divided by West Truck Road. The area where this year’s removal action was conducted is located in the northern portion and includes a former gasoline station, a former bus terminal, a suspected waste disposal pit, piles of sand and debris, a depression area, and a drainage swale along Connery Avenue. Four site investigations were performed at the CS-4 site from 1994-2000. In 1994, a thermal treatment plant unit was used to treat over 13,000 tons of soil that was removed from the southern portion of the CS-4 site. The primary contaminants in the soil at the CS-4 site were lead, zinc, pesticides, polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), petroleum hydrocarbons and solvents. However, PCBs were not detected in the northern portion of CS-4 which is currently undergoing remediation. This soil removal was being performed under a Engineering Evaluation/Cost Analysis (EE/CA) for CS-4 that was submitted to the public for comment in September 2001. An Action Memorandum, which documents the final remedy selected for a particular source area site, was issued in January 2002. Excavation and off-site disposal of contaminated soils was selected and currently is underway.

 

FS-2 Record of Decision Signed
In February 2002, AFCEE and EPA with concurrence from the MassDEP finalized a Record of Decision (ROD) on the Fuel Spill 2 (FS-2) area of contamination. A ROD is the formal mechanism for closing out the site under EPA Superfund cleanup regulations. The FS-2 ROD specified a no further action at the site because all activities associated with the site for both soil and groundwater have been completed.

From 1955 to 1965, the 5.5 acre site on MMR was used for unloading petroleum products from railroad tank cars and tanker trucks. Since 1985, several investigations have been conducted to sample and analyze soil and groundwater. In 1991, a Remedial Investigation (RI) concluded that surface soil at the site was contaminated. In 1996, approximately 520 tons of petroleum-contaminated surface soil were excavated and hauled off base following federal and state guidelines. Recent investigations in 1998 and 2000 concluded that the surface and subsurface soil, and groundwater do not pose a significant risk to human health and the environment.

Chemical Spill 10 (CS-10) Soil Treatment System
A soil vapor extraction system (SVE) began operation in March 2002 at the Chemical Spill 10 (CS-10) source area to remove volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from the subsurface soil. SVE treatment systems take advantage of the volatile property of VOCs to remove them from the soil. Contaminants are pulled off the soil into a vapor form by applying an air vacuum through a system of extraction wells. The CS-10 SVE system is expected to operate for 3 years. Other SVE systems operating at MMR include the Petroleum Fuel Storage Area (PFSA) and the LF-2 source areas.    

Cleanup Alternatives Being Analyzed for the Leading Edge of CS-10
Environmental investigations conducted in 2000 and 2001 helped AFCEE identify the leading edge (the furthest point to which a plume has moved) of the CS-10 groundwater plume. There are four fingers associated with the leading edge of CS-10: the Northern Lobe (formerly known as the TCE plume), the North Central Lobe, the South Central Lobe, and the Southern Lobe. 

Alternatives for cleaning up the leading edge portions of the CS-10 groundwater plume were developed this spring in a draft Feasibility Study (FS). AFCEE uses nine criteria, required by EPA Superfund law, to select a cleanup plan or remedy that has the best balance of protecting human health and the environment, maintaining protection over time, and minimizing untreated contamination. Of these nine criteria, protection of human health and compliance with Applicable or Relevant and Appropriate Requirements (ARARs) are considered threshold criteria that must be met for a cleanup alternative to be selected. The next five criteria, called balancing criteria, are used to evaluate and compare alternatives. These criteria help to evaluate how effectively each alternative would meet the CS-10 cleanup goals; whether or not each cleanup alternative could be constructed; how each alternative potentially would affect the surrounding natural ecosystem; and how cost-effective each alternative would be at reaching cleanup goals. State and community concerns are considered modifying criteria factored into a final balancing of all criteria to select a remedy. Consideration of state, PCT, and community comments may prompt AFCEE to modify aspects of the preferred alternative or decide that another alternative provides a more appropriate balance.

The next step in the cleanup process, after the FS, is called the Proposed Plan where a preferred alternative for cleaning up the entire CS-10 groundwater plume is presented to the public. The Proposed Plan is issued with a 30-day public comment period so that the public has the opportunity to comment on the preferred alternative. A public hearing is held during this comment period, offering the public an opportunity to make oral comments and/or submit written comments. These comments help the AFCEE and regulatory agencies understand how acceptable each of the cleanup alternatives are to the affected neighborhood residents and the general public. During this formal public comment period, modifications can be made to the proposed alternatives to address public concerns. Public acceptability is an important criteria in making final cleanup decisions. The final decision will be documented in a Record of Decision, which includes a Responsiveness Summary in which responses are provided for all public comments received.

Preliminary alternatives for cleaning up the entire CS-10 plume have been discussed at PCT meetings in Dec. 2001, Jan. and Feb. 2002. A fact sheet entitled "Final Groundwater Cleanup Decisions" and PCT meeting minutes are available on the IRP web site at www.mmr.org.

The public will have an opportunity to comment on the Proposed Plan including all alternatives for the entire CS-10 groundwater plume during the public comment period scheduled for January 2003.

 

CS-10 and SD-5 Groundwtaer Treatment System Map

 

Residential Well Sampling Offered this Summer
AFCEE offers Resident Well Sampling as part of its commitment to ensure public health is protected. AFCEE tests specific residential wells, typically once a year although some are more frequent, for VOCs and/or ethylene dibromide (EDB). This year sampling activities will occur in July. In order for your well to be sampled, your private well must be your only source of drinking water. Currently, 55 homes are part of the Residential Well Sampling Program. 451 private wells were sampled in 2001. AFCEE has connected over 900 residences to municipal water since 1986.

To check on your eligibility for free sampling or for more information, please contact Doug Karson at (508) 968-4678 ext. 2. Additional information on the Residential Well Sampling Program can be found on the IRP web site.

Your private well may be eligible for testing if it meets any of the following criteria:

• An MMR groundwater plume flows beneath your home  
• The MMR groundwater plume is expected to underflow your home within two years 
• Your home is located within 500 feet of the edge of an MMR groundwater plume


Air Force Begins Five-Year Review for IRP Sites
In 1989, the Massachusetts Military Reservation (MMR) was added to the US Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA’s) National Priorities List, more commonly known as "Superfund". As part of the Superfund process, EPA requires five-year reviews. The purpose of the five year review is to evaluate the protectiveness of site remedies to ensure human health and the environment.

This year, AFCEE will be conducting the five-year review on all IRP sites. AFCEE will begin the five-year review process with an announcement in a separate newsletter and an IRP Community Involvement Specialist will work with the community during the review.

The five-year review addresses the protectiveness of final cleanup decisions by determining if the selected remedy functions as intended in the decision document; ensuring that exposure assumptions, toxicity data, cleanup levels, and remedial action objective used at the time of the remedy selection are still valid; and evaluating any other new sources of information that could question the protectiveness of the remedy.

AFCEE welcomes information from people who are familiar with the sites. We encourage the public to tell us about any activities at the site, such as, vandalism, trespassing, and/or unusual activities. We are also interested in hearing about ways the cleanup at the site has helped the area. There are several ways to contact us:

Telephone: Frank Adinolfi at (508) 968-4670 ext. 5983
E-mail: frank.adinolfi@mmr.brooks.af.mil
Online: http://www.mmr.org
In person: PCT or SMB citizen advisory team meetings
Mail: HQ AFCEE/MMR
Attn: Frank Adinolfi
322 East Inner Road
Otis ANGB, MA 02542

Studies on Cranberries and Ethylene Dibromide Completed
In 1998, after it was discovered that ethylene dibromide (EDB) contaminated groundwater was upwelling into the cranberry bogs along the Coonamessett and Quashnet river systems, AFCEE consulted with Kansas State University (KSU) to conduct a study. The results of the study are detailed in a report entitled, " Assessing The Uptake of Ethylene Dibromide by Cranberry (Vaccinium macrocarpon) Plant, dated November 29, 2001.

Vaccinium macrocarpon

The study investigated the uptake of EDB by cranberry plants from EDB contaminated water and the distribution of EDB in cranberry plants once taken up by the plants. KSU conducted the study in a controlled greenhouse in Kansas, using cranberry vines and soil from Cape Cod. Small quantities of EDB were introduced into the root system of the plants and then studied over two growing seasons. During the first season, which did not produce any berries, it was found that plant leaves and stems absorbed EDB. When the plant tissue showed maximum EDB absorption capacity, the EDB would disperse from the leaves into the surrounding atmosphere. It is important to note that if EDB was ever introduced into the atmosphere, the low concentration would not pose a health risk. During the second season, which again did not produce any berries, it was discovered that EDB was not detected in the plant leaves or stems suggesting that long-term soil exposure to EDB could have made the plants develop some sort of EDB-degrading microorganism. 

Copies of the report are available at the Bourne, Falmouth, Mashpee, Sandwich local libraries and town halls, as well as on base at the USCG library (base pass required). For more information or to request a base pass, contact Doug Karson, Community Involvement Specialist at (508) 968-4678 ext. 2 or toll free, (866) GO-AFCEE.

Contacts

AFCEE/MMR US EPA
For more information about
the Installation Restoration
Program, contact:
For more information about the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, contact:
Doug Karson
Community Involvement Specialist

HQ AFCEE/MMR
322 East Inner Road
Otis ANG Base, MA 02542

Phone: (508) 968–4678 x. 2
Toll Free: (866) GO–AFCEE
E–mail: doug.karson@mmr.brooks.af.mil

Jim Murphy
Community Involvement
Coordinator

USEPA New England Region, Suite 1100
One Congress Street (RAA)
Boston, MA 02203

Phone: (617) 918–1028
Fax: (617) 918–1029
Toll free: (888) 372–7341
E–mail: murphy.jim@epa.gov

  

MassDEP MA DPH
For more information about the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Agency, contact: For more information about the Massachusetts Department of Public Health, contact:
Ellie Grillo
Community Involvement
Coordinator

MassDEP
20 Riverside Drive
Lakeville, MA 02346

Phone: (508) 946–2866
Fax: (508) 947–6557
E–mail: ellie.grillo@state.ma.us
Dave Williams
Senior Environmental Analyst

Massachusetts DPH
3137 Richardson Road
Otis ANGB, MA 02542

Phone: (508) 968-4366
Fax: (508) 968-4365
E–mail: dave.williams@state.ma.us


Mailing List Request
To have your name placed on the site mailing list concerning the groundwater remediation program at MMR, please complete our on-line form.

footer graphic